Posts Tagged identity

Facebook group celebrates girls binge drinking, what does this say about our culture(s)?

An interesting article was brought to my attention via Twitter this afternoon.  Melanie McBride tweeted an article written last December that presents the complex issue of self celebration on the web through a particularly unsettling case of a Facebook group named 30 Reasons Girls Should Call It A Night where thousands of posted pictures depict (mostly) girls drinking, partying, and in many cases engaging in all out debauchery.  The group is a relatively large online community within Facebook ostensibly centered around the nightlife ritual of binge drinking.  Thousands of pictures, videos, and a robust discussion thread are found on the group’s page where members discuss everything from the best alcoholic drinks to mix to the weirdest thoughts they’ve had while vomiting.

Now I’m not writing this to pass judgment.  Lord knows I’ve engaged in such debauchery many-a-time (many of us have, c’mon admit it), and that’s precisely my point.  The increased transparency allowed by many web applications (social networks being the most popularly debated and criticized) is creating situations where we are forced to confront the strange space where our private and public behaviors interface.  As the more conservative of us decry the increased awareness of less-than-socially-acceptable behavior as evidence of the corruption of our youth and claim anymore “nothing is sacred,” others of us see the possible enlightening truth behind it all – this behavior, to varying degrees, has always been practiced.  What’s different is the changing technological landscape that pushes helps push our private selves to the fore for all to see (though, this is not to say cultural norms and values are static).  What we are seeing is not the despicable behaviors of others and ourselves, but rather our common humanity.  Now before some of you protest that lying in the fetal position next to a toilet in a puddle of your own vomit is not the warm and fuzzy essence of humanity that we all share, think about it for a minute.  No one would claim they are perfect, obviously.  We all make mistakes, we all go wild, we all experience fear, embarrassment.  Why should these essential experiences of the human condition take a backstage to happiness, love, and joy?

I’d like to think my own nightlife behavior is a bit more controlled than many of the people depicted in 30 Reasons Why, but maybe not.  I certainly recognize that any representation of me, be it a photograph or video, can be misinterpreted and possibly damage my future, so I passively avoid putting myself in such situations.  There is a high premium on our front stage face, one that is separate from the face we keep back stage, and online identity management is important, I won’t deny that, but maybe this is changing.  I also think that a healthy restraint on the content you publish online about yourself is a good thing.  That’s just me.  It’s different for others.  In addition to the discussions about the craziest things they’ve done while drinking, the members of 30 Reasons Why are also discussing topics with names like “Your Internet Life” and “Private versus Public” where as a community they are grappling with the issues mentioned in this post.

I’d love to hear your thoughts on this, since, obviously, its tremendously complex and I’ve only begun to scratch the surface here.

Comments (4)

Managing our digital identities

There’s a great post over at Swift Kick Central covering some important issues about digital identity management. It hits on a lot of things I bring up in my senior thesis about the merging of information-systems (which I ultimately got from Joshua Meyrowitz in his book No Sense of Place) and what this might mean in terms of identity negotiation. The post starts by discussing the often dreaded reality of employers using Google as well as social networking sites to gain information about new hires. With rare exception, it seems this side of the issue is what is brought up the most in conversations about internet privacy and information access. danah boyd wrote a blog post a while ago touching on this stuff. She recommended creating a virtual identity and protecting it. I thought this was very good advice and I immediately created a virtual identity of my own, a place where I could post everything “me”; my accomplishments, my contact information, my blog, etc. Anything I felt was relevant to my professional life. I figured this was a much better approach than just sitting back and letting my old net behavior pop up in search engines for everyone to see (please, don’t go looking! ;-) ). Not to mention, it’s much more convenient just to send people to my web page if they need that “me” stuff.

Anyways, I was glad to see the post over at Swift Kick mention this with regard to employers. The following is actually from a post that Swift Kick comments on:

When you have some applicants lined up for a teaching vacancy, do you “Google” them? Seems a pretty large majority say that yes, they do take some time to see what a standard Google search might pull up about a potential hire. And some even admit to doing a cursory MySpace search to see what comes up. In most cases, they say that the intent is primarily to find out if there is anything negative that surfaces. Almost all of them admit, however, that finding positive things about their applicants, as in portfolios or collaborations or even social sites, does or could make a positive difference in the process.

Swift Kick follows up with

The main point of our training, The Secrets Behind Facebook and Myspace, is to use the megaphone of technology to promote your good qualities so you leave positive footprints for people who want to find out about you.

That’s awesome. The megaphone metaphor is perfect. If we teach people the ins and outs of their digital identiti(es) so they know how to better manage them, we can create an image of the Web characterized by conscious self promotion rather than privacy intrusion.

The post goes on to discuss how this sort of sensibility should be worked into school curricula. Presently, we are in a technological situation where many more people know much more about many more people. Whereas before identity was in large part dependent on the control of information access; who has access versus who doesn’t. Today such access is granted to many more people. This calls for us to rethink our conception of identity, and in this case digital identity. I would love to see these sorts of issues being discussed in the classroom!

Leave a Comment